Which type of headset is best for you?

Published by Joel Willans on February 1, 2013

Screen Shot 2013-02-01 at 08.43.41

The celebrated Ethiopian distance runner Haile Gebrselassie is famous for setting world records, while listening to the pop song “Scatman.” Most of us don’t have such heady goals when enjoying our tunes and conversation, but we still want our music and chat  to sound great. 

The best way to guarantee fantastic audio is by using a great smartphone, but what about the headset? If you’re not sure about the pros and cons of the different types read on.

Over-ear or circum-aural

First off over-ear or circum aural headsets. These have circular or ellipsoid earpads that cover the entire ear. This design means that music leakage is kept to a minimum and consequently over ear headset have the best bass. Over ear headsets can also be designed to fully seal against the head and so reduce external noise. The down sides? Well, because of their size they can be heavy and wearing them too long can be uncomfortable.

On-ear or supra-aural

Supra-aural or on-ear headsets have earpads, which sit on the top of the ear rather than around them. On ear headsets are renowned for their comfort and are less prone to overheating. Some models can also fold up for easier transport. The main disadvantages are that generally they have less impressive hi-fi and unless they have very good active noise cancellation, such as the Nokia Purity Pro Wireless Stereo Headset by Monster, you hear more of the surrounding world.

NokiaPurityIntra-concha or ear buds

Intra concha or ear buds, like the Nokia BH-118 are very much smaller in size and are placed directly outside of the ear canal, but without fully enveloping it. Generally inexpensive, they’re also extremely portable and convenient. However, they don’t cancel out any external sound and due to their size their bass frequencies are more limited.

bh118_6In-ear or canalphone

Finally, the fourth type, in-ear or canalphone headsets are placed directly inside your ear channel. They also act as earplugs and are ideal for when insulation from outside sound is needed. What’s more, universal in-ear headsets, like the Nokia Purity In-Ear, provide you with a selection of different sized earplugs to fit a wide variety of ear canals. The main issue is comfort. Some people simply don’t like things stuck inside their ear.

NokiaPurityinearSo there you have a quick summary of the pros and cons of today’s headsets. Need any other info let us know in the comments section and we’ll do our best to help you out.

Comments

  • http://www.facebook.com/jari.hietaniemi.9 Jari Hietaniemi

    You might make an another similar article that would be categorized by activity. People always “do” something while using headset. Whether doing is sports; running (bumby movement), gym (wires and straps are on way), swimming (water), snowboarding (helmet).. Or everyday activity; sleeping (small buds), commuting (loud environment), teleconference (phone capabilities), sauna..

    • http://www.facebook.com/joel.willans Joel Willans

      Thanks for sharing, Jari! That’s a great idea. Watch this space :)

  • http://NokiaPhones.fr Allan

    The Nokia Purity Pro Wireless Stereo Headset by Monster is perfect for my hear, but I still can’t buy it Nokia, since its announcement on the 5th September! Come on!

    • Francois Magny

      I feel the same way.

  • http://twitter.com/Alvetica Al Pavangkanan

    Purity Pros for travel, Purity in-ears for most other activities.

  • http://113tidbits.com/ tony greene

    Purity Pros look great. Any available for review?

  • amalik

    AIAIAI TMA-1 definitely !

  • http://www.facebook.com/renaissanceronin Renaissance Ronin

    “In Ear” headphones rule. Be it helmet, headgear or anything else, they seem to stay where you need them without worry or obstruction. Now if they just made a wireless “In Ear”… (sigh!)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1343147795 Sonia Myers

    Liking the Nokia Purity Pro Wireless Stereo Headset by Monster – in white to match my Apple equip :)

  • http://twitter.com/srivatsan316 Srivatsan

    In-ear canalphones for me. I hate those heavy over the ear ones except when i am in a meeting somehow the mic along with it works for me. That apart when i am driving/walking/jogging/wanna do some hands-free talking in-ear’s the best.

  • http://www.facebook.com/remi.vladuceanu Remi Vladuceanu

    Over-ear or circum-aural would be best for me. I use one for several years now ;)

  • http://bajabybus.com/ Baja By Bus

    Over-ear suits me best!

  • bobdebilder

    certainly an interesting article .. Scatman singer suffered from ‘stuttering’ so the song was always of more interest to me :o)

  • http://www.austinbriggs.com Austin Briggs

    As much as I like the in-ear headphones on the go, I vote for the circum-aural ones. Can’t compare the quality of the sound.

  • Harold Gardner

    Thanks for pointing out the considerations toward this decision.

  • http://www.facebook.com/tomlaing Tom Laing

    I’ve moved from over ear to in the ear – works for me

  • http://www.newsmeback.com NewsMeBack

    I prefer ear buds, they suit me best.

  • http://www.facebook.com/MarkAReynolds Mark Reynolds

    Thanks for the ‘heads-up’ on this interesting topic.

  • http://twitter.com/robloc robloc

    Yes, it really would be useful to have a categories section accordiung to what you are doing when you listen. Look forward to developments here.

  • Ernie Meyer

    I use over the ear with mic for my webinars and all my Internet radio broadcasts & commercial productions.

  • http://twitter.com/MyBriefcases MyBriefcases.com

    great post…

  • http://www.myspace.com/charlieslang Charles Slang

    I use in-ear cannal type for exercise and for monitoring live audio performances. I use circumaural, semi-open-air design headphones for Home Stereo and AV listening, and I use circumaural closed-back type for recording and mixing. I have several of each type.

  • http://twitter.com/NWRUGS NW Rugs

    ear buds

  • http://twitter.com/tag64geoff geoff tegjeu

    rather not use any headset but the choice is up to the individual, cheers

    • Ahmed Mustafa Nematallah

      yeah, loudspeakers certainly beat all, and they don’t damage your ears

  • Samuel Schmid

    I definatively prefer the In-ear plugs for a dense bass sound.

  • woaksie

    I want an article about the switch on the ear buds that come with my 920. What can it be used for and how?

    • http://twitter.com/dalydose Jeff Daly

      Jealous that your 920 came with ear buds…they left that out of the box here in the US.

      • woaksie

        Don’t be too jealous, they are very cheap and cheerful.

  • CutenessOverload

    I use on-ear headphones as they are very comfortable – perfect for when you’re listening to a lot of things for a long time.

  • http://twitter.com/dalydose Jeff Daly

    I prefer the in-ear bud style. They tend to stay on, even while running and they block most of the noise, but not so much that you won’t hear a horn or emergency vehicle.

  • Matthew Paul

    I want to buy the Purity Pro’s so badly. When will they become available on Amazon?!

  • Ahmed Mustafa Nematallah

    #1 and #3 suck, #3 just falls whenever I move my head, #2 is the best, but it isn’t portable, #4 is great

  • jlangfel

    I like #3 for doing stuff and #1 when working in the PC

  • http://twitter.com/DaveSvenson Dave Svenson

    I use skullcandy

  • http://twitter.com/mmwalker mmwalker

    i have a great simple headset that I wear in bed – it’s a headband and it the earbuds are in the fabric. When I am around town I use the device that I answers my phone and when I am in bed I use the headband. I’d love it if you had a headband headset!!!

  • gadgety

    I find it simply amazing how you don’t even mention Nokia’s BH-610 Essence in ear with both passive and active noise cancellation, bluetooth and APT-X!! It’s the most advanced head set on the market.